Lesson 1 of 6

What is an Argument?

Learn to tell the difference between an argument and a mere opinion, and start spotting claims and reasons in everything you read.

Introduction

It is not a fight.

In everyday life, "argument" often means a heated quarrel. In critical thinking, it means something different and far more useful.

A critical thinking argument is: a set of statements where some statements (the premises) are offered as reasons to believe another statement (the conclusion).

Arguments are how we justify beliefs, make decisions, and reason together. Without them, we are just asserting things.

The Core Formula

Claims + Reasons = Argument

Argument = Conclusion (C) + at least one Premise (P)

The conclusion is the main claim: what someone is trying to get you to believe or do.

The premises are the supporting reasons: the evidence, facts, or logic offered in favour of the conclusion.

No reasons = not an argument. Just a statement, preference, or assertion.

Examples

See it in the wild

Click each example to reveal the argument structure.

🚲"We should add more bike lanes to this street."

"We should add more bike lanes to this street because cycling reduces traffic, lowers emissions, and improves public health."

C: We should add more bike lanes.

P1: Cycling reduces traffic.

P2: It lowers emissions.

P3: It improves public health.

This is an argument. Reasons support a conclusion.

📱"I love this app."

"I love this app. It's just so good!"

C: The app is good.

No premises given. Restating the claim more forcefully does not count as a reason.

Not an argument. This is an assertion.

🖼️"This image must be AI-generated."

"This image must be AI-generated. The hands have six fingers and the background text is illegible."

C: The image is AI-generated.

P1: The hands have six fingers.

P2: The background text is illegible.

Argument. Specific evidence supports the conclusion.

🎵"The concert sold out."

"The concert sold out in three minutes."

This is a factual statement. A single claim with no reasons attached to a further conclusion.

Not an argument on its own. It is just a report.

📰"Screen time rules should change."

"Schools should restrict phone use during lessons because attention spans are shorter when devices are present, and students retain more when they take handwritten notes."

C: Schools should restrict phone use in lessons.

P1: Attention spans are shorter when devices are present.

P2: Students retain more from handwritten notes.

Argument. A policy claim backed by two reasons.

Quick Checks

Check your understanding

Answer each question to unlock the next one.

Q1. Which of the following is an argument?
A"The weather is terrible today."
B"You should carry an umbrella because the forecast shows a 90% chance of rain."
C"Rain is wet."
D"I don't like rainy days at all."
Q2. In the argument "We should tax sugary drinks because obesity rates are rising and sugar is a major contributor" - what is the conclusion?
AObesity rates are rising.
BSugar is a major contributor to obesity.
CWe should tax sugary drinks.
DTaxes reduce consumption.
Q3. True or False: "This film is the best of the decade" is an argument.
ATrue
BFalse
Q4. In "Remote work increases productivity because employees avoid long commutes and report higher focus at home" - which is a premise?
AEmployees avoid long commutes.
BRemote work increases productivity.
CWorking from home is popular.
DOffices are expensive.
Q5. Complete: "This restaurant deserves five stars ______ the food is exceptional and service was warm." Type the missing word that signals a premise:
Mini-Game

Spot the Argument

Spot the Argument

8 posts. Tap Argument if it has a conclusion plus at least one reason. Tap Not Argument if it is just a statement, feeling, or assertion.

Card: 1/8  |  Score: 0

Practice Round

Five quick rounds

Question 1 of 5
Which sentence contains both a conclusion and a premise?
A"The sky is blue."
B"I really enjoy hiking."
C"We should invest in renewables because fossil fuels are finite."
D"Pizza is delicious, obviously."
Question 2 of 5
True or False: An argument can have more than one premise.
AFalse
BTrue
Question 3 of 5
Fill in: The supporting reasons in an argument are called ______.
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following is NOT a sign that a statement is a premise?
AIt starts with "because"
BIt starts with "since"
CIt follows "given that"
DIt starts with "therefore"
Question 5 of 5
Fill in: The main claim an argument is trying to prove is called the ______.

Practice round complete. Ready for the reflection.

Reflection

Now it is your turn

Think of a recent opinion you expressed or heard. Something like "this policy is bad" or "that decision was wrong."

Rewrite it as a proper argument: add at least two premises that genuinely support the conclusion.

Tip: Premise indicators include because, since, given that, as shown by. Conclusion indicators include therefore, so, thus, hence.